Every Super Mario game ranked by Metacritic score
Super Mario Galaxy 2 tops this ranking with 98/100, ahead of Super Mario Galaxy (97/100) and Super Mario Odyssey (97/100). Metacritic critic scores. 18 games ranked.
⚔ Higher or lower?
Which one got the higher Metacritic score?
| # | Game | Number | Date | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Super Mario Galaxy 2Metascore, Wii version | 98/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 2 | Super Mario GalaxyMetascore, Wii version (73 reviews) | 97/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 3 | Super Mario OdysseyCritic Metascore, Nintendo Switch | 97/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 4 | Super Mario 64Metascore, Nintendo 64 | 94/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 5 | Super Mario 3D WorldMetascore, Wii U version (83 reviews) | 93/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 6 | Super Mario Bros. WonderMetascore, Switch version | 92/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 7 | Super Mario SunshineMetascore, GameCube version (61 reviews) | 92/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 8 | Super Mario 3D LandMetascore, Nintendo 3DS version | 90/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 9 | New Super Mario Bros.Metascore, Nintendo DS version (65 reviews) | 89/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 10 | Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's FuryMetascore, Nintendo Switch version | 89/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 11 | Super Mario Maker 2Metascore, Nintendo Switch version | 88/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 12 | New Super Mario Bros. WiiMetascore, Wii version | 87/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 13 | Super Mario RPGMetascore, Nintendo Switch version (114 reviews) | 84/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 14 | Captain Toad: Treasure TrackerMetascore, Wii U version (78 reviews) | 81/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 15 | New Super Mario Bros. U DeluxeMetascore, Nintendo Switch version | 80/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 16 | New Super Mario Bros. 2Metascore, Nintendo 3DS version (70 reviews) | 78/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 17 | Super Mario RunMetascore, iOS (64 reviews) | 76/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
| 18 | Super Mario Bros. 35Metascore, Nintendo Switch version (29 reviews) | 75/100 | October 2026 | Metacritic |
Related rankings
- Every Super Mario game ranked by copies sold
- Every Super Mario game ranked by length
- The best-rated video games
- Every Age of Empires game ranked by Metacritic score
- Every Animal Crossing game ranked by Metacritic score
- Every Assassin's Creed game ranked by Metacritic score
- Every Battlefield game ranked by Metacritic score
- Every Borderlands game ranked by Metacritic score
- Every Call of Duty game ranked by Metacritic score
- Every Diablo game ranked by Metacritic score
- Every Donkey Kong game ranked by Metacritic score
- Every Fallout game ranked by Metacritic score
Think you know gaming numbers? 5 questions a day, a slider, a leaderboard.
PLAY TODAY'S MISSION